Re: [Fis] 2004 FIS session: concluding comments

Dear Bob

Does you view (Stan, An excellent encapsulation of the "dialectical"
nature of the living universe!) entail that:
1. The universe is alive.
2. Life can fully be explained in physical, chemical and objective
informational terms?

My view is that certainly life and mind (first person experiences)
emerge within the evolution of the universe. This means that either we
must put these qualities as an inherent part of the universe and then
realize it is not fully explainable on the present metaphysics of
'science'. Or that they emerge later in evolution (mysteriously, I
think) and then we again have problems explaining the qualitatively new
phenomena 'scientifically'.

Robert Ulanowicz wrote:
>
> On Tue, 15 Jun 2004, Stanley N. Salthe wrote:
>
> > As a philosopher of nature, I would like to again present my view
> > of the BIG picture here. ( So far, no physicists I have presented this
> > to have objected.) We have two basic tendencies in Nature --
> > collecting/centripetal versus cascading/centrifugal. The first,
> > (historically: decoherence -> strong forces -> gravitation ->
> > organization, all showing increasing 'information') occurred because the
> > acceleration of expansion in the Big Bang has been so great that the
> > system went rapidly out of equilibrium and is still doing that. The
> > collecting is just an aspect of acceleration. The "equal and opposite"
> > reaction of the Universe we call the Second Law of thermodynamics,
> > referring to the tendency of the Universe to regain thermodynamic
> > equilibrium. (We can asume that the Universe is an isolated system
> > because it could not expand acceleratedly if it were not effectively
> > so.)
>
> Stan, An excellent encapsulation of the "dialectical" nature of the living
> universe! I will only add that these opposing propensities, as the occur
> in ecosystem trophic networks, can be quantified using information -
> theoretic indices. (Ecology, the Ascendent Perspective. Columbia
> University Press, 1997.)
>
> > Inasmuch as effective work cannot be done with much greater energy
> > efficiency than about 50% on average, it is clear that the production of
> > organization and order through this route is yet another way to help the
> > Universe on its way toward equilibrium. Viewed this way, the Second Law
> > is a final cause of everything that happens.
>
> As the two of us have discussed many times before, however, I do not agree
> that the order- creating propensities must be considered ontologically
> subservient to the tendencies of the Second Law. As with all dialectical-
> like configurations, causality should be considered intractably mutual.
> (Is gravity *subservient* to the Second Law?)
>
> > So, we are less than maximally accelerated substance, sometimes called
> > 'negentropy'.
>
> My preference is away from considering living entities as "substance" and
> favors more the notion of "configurations of processes". (As Popper put
> it, "... we are not things, but flames ... nets of chemical
> *processes* ...")
>
> Furthermore, I tend to eschew Schroedinger's term "negentropy", because it
> maintains one's focus on entropy as the primary attribute and because it
> refers to a state, rather than to an amalgamation of processes.
>
> Bob
>
> -------------------------------------------------------------------------
> Robert E. Ulanowicz | Tel: (410) 326-7266
> Chesapeake Biological Laboratory | FAX: (410) 326-7378
> P.O. Box 38 | Email <ulan@cbl.umces.edu>
> 1 Williams Street | Web <http://www.cbl.umces.edu/~ulan>
> Solomons, MD 20688-0038 |
> --------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> _______________________________________________
> fis mailing list
> fis@listas.unizar.es
> http://webmail.unizar.es/mailman/listinfo/fis

-- 
Venlig hilsen/Best wishes S�ren Brier
Handelsh�jskolen K�benhavn/Copenhagen Business School
Inst. For Ledelse, Politik og Filosofi/Dept. of Management, Politics and
Philosophy, Bl�g�rdsgade/Blaagaardsgade 23 B, 3. floor, room 326,
DK-2200 Copenhagen N.
Telephone +45 38152208, mail sbr.lpf@cbs.dk .
Old home page with full text papers:
http://www.flec.kvl.dk/personalprofile.asp?id=sbr&p=engelsk
Ed. of Cybernetics & Human Knowing http://www.imprint-academic.com/C&HK  
Subscriptions sandra@imprint.co.uk,
_______________________________________________
fis mailing list
fis@listas.unizar.es
http://webmail.unizar.es/mailman/listinfo/fis